Saturday, May 20, 2006

The Prince

Machiavelli's The Prince is famous for the author's unapologetic advocacy of realpolitik, and I found it lived up to its reputation. It's a quick read, clearly written, and Machiavelli pulls no punches. I'd recommend it just to see for yourself what everyone means when they say "Machiavellian."

I don't have quotes, but I will paraphrase two bits of advice he gives. First, he recommends that a ruler be "cruel" rather than "kind," because a kind ruler will not be feared and will constantly have to be dealing with insubordination, insurrection, and the like, probably with harsh measures. Whereas the "cruel" ruler will quickly gain a reputation for cruelty, will be feared, and will not have to deal with much rebellion, thus in the end being in practice more kind than the "kind" ruler.

On whether to be truthful, Machiavelli advises that a ruler should keep his or her word as often as it is beneficial. The people you are dealing with will break their pledges to you as soon as it becomes advantageous to do so, Machiavelli says, so you should double-cross them first.

Very provocative, and gives very good insight into politics and politicians, although no politician today would be caught dead saying out loud what Machiavelli says. So while I find myself disagreeing with much of what he says, and softening other parts ("don't say 'be cruel,' say 'establish firm justice'"), I also find myself welcoming his forthrightness as a breath of fresh air.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

Shortly after reading this post, I got the May 29 issue of the New Yorker in the mail to illustrate Machiavelli's point. There's a cartoon on p. 58 showing a huge bearded guy wearing skins and a viking hat, grasping a spear with a skull on top, sitting on a throne, flanked by slightly less huge guys holding double-bladed axes. In front of him is a chained dog, baring its teeth and salivating. Facing him there's another guy, standing behind two men prostrate on the floor. The other guy is reading from a scroll, saying, "The latest poll showsw your approval rating holding steady at a hundred per cent." (And so how many words was that cartoon picture worth?)