My comment about the kids' souls wasn't so much a condemnation of their actions as a sort of motherly surge of anxiety. It just seemed to me that they were having to face a ton of more disturbing things, and they seemed so young. Part of it was their more mature clothes. You know the thing parents always say, "They grow up too soon!" I don't know where that is coming from in my case, but I just want to protect them. Not that that would do them any good. So it was a strictly emotional comment, not a moralistic one.
To respond to the moralistic critiques, though, I would say that Harry's breaking of the rules is not necessarily laudable but certainly understandable. I think realistic characters are good. I don't know what kind of fiction these conservative fathers read. Probably none.
About the ineffectiveness of the adults, I think that's true to a certain extent. There are seemingly a lot of bumbling adults. But I think a lot of it only results from the kids' refusal to be helped. Dumbledore is just what Harry needs - a powerful person he can trust - but Harry avoids him. He's always afraid to tell him the truth. It is the classic stiff-necked Israelite scenario.
Sirius is an example of an adult with some serious flaws and insecurities. Lupin has some problems, but I think his power is understated. So is Dumbledore's. Understatement is one of the things I most admire about the books. J.K. Rowling is able to let misunderstandings remain for a long time before she corrects them.
Saturday, July 24, 2004
Saturday, July 03, 2004
Many cities
He left me crying late one Sunday night, outside of Boulder.
He said he had to find himself, out on the road.
- Jo Dee Messina, "Stand Beside Me"
Last time I saw her it was getting colder
But that was years ago.
Last I heard she had moved to Boulder
But where she's now I don't know.
- Garth Brooks, "What She's Doing Now"
The next challenge is to find or write songs that include the names of all the cities I will spend a night in before July is over. They are:
Eugene, Oregon; Chicago; London; Addis Ababa; Mekelle, Ethiopia; and Philadelphia.
Bonus points for including cities where I have a layover: Phoenix, Las Vegas, and Amsterdam.
Good luck.
He said he had to find himself, out on the road.
- Jo Dee Messina, "Stand Beside Me"
Last time I saw her it was getting colder
But that was years ago.
Last I heard she had moved to Boulder
But where she's now I don't know.
- Garth Brooks, "What She's Doing Now"
The next challenge is to find or write songs that include the names of all the cities I will spend a night in before July is over. They are:
Eugene, Oregon; Chicago; London; Addis Ababa; Mekelle, Ethiopia; and Philadelphia.
Bonus points for including cities where I have a layover: Phoenix, Las Vegas, and Amsterdam.
Good luck.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Links
- the Evil Line
- Arts & Letters Daily
- Creole-English dictionary
- Chocolate and Zucchini
- pedestrian empowerment
- the diary of Samuel Pepys
- plant of the day
- Language Log
- wild parrots of Brooklyn
- learning to love you more
- Nabaztag
- plant image library
- geography practice
- tying shoelaces
- find a library cat near you